Defining the envelope
We flew today. Winds continued to blow
20-25 kts during the morning so we postponed flights until afternoon.
Once that decision was made, we decided to assemble the launcher and
if winds were under 25 kts in the afternoon, we would fly Malolo 1
off the launcher. We had two objectives:
-
Test launcher operations from a
ship.
-
Push operational weather envelope
up a few knotches to determine what the upper limits for normal
shipboard flight operations should be. Specifically, we wanted to
find wind and sea state limits.
The safe boat generally has a limit of
around 25 kts winds. Getting the safe boat off the ship and back on
board gets difficult in higher winds and seas so the risk factor of
injury or damage occurring goes up significantly. For the
Resolution, the risk factor with higher winds comes into play with
the take-off stage, landing stage and the recovery stage. Once in
flight, the Resolution UAS does not care how hard the winds are
blowing as long as they are not extremely gusty. The video data feed
coming from the UAS has a diminishing return once the winds get above
15 kts as the sea state starts to hide objects with foam and breaking
waves. Other sensors we might use, may not be affected by sea state.
We wanted to test for reasonable wind limits and find out what
would cause the highest risk towards operations.
The afternoon plan was slightly delayed
when the ship called an abandon ship drill right after lunch. Winds
had not come down significantly but they remained under 25 kts so we
decided lauanch was a go. With the safe boat in the water, we
readied Malolo 1 on the launcher. The winds were gusting on the bow
as they hit the ship and the bridge behind us and caused an swirling
eddy. Once off the end of the launcher though, the UAS would find
clean steady air blowing just over 20 kts right on it's nose. All it
had to do was make it off the launcher.... which it did just fine.
Malolo 1 jumped into the air and climbed out sharply as Curt applied
power. Relieved to be flying, the UAS would have been happy to go
somewhere but Curt cut power and flying a very fast wind blown
downwind, turned base and then final where Malolo 1 once again had
it's nose to the wind and relative speed over the water down to just
a few knots. Timing the waves and swell, Curt landed it in the ocean
like it was another day at the flying field. The safe boat came up
from behind to retrieve it. Watching them from the bow of the ship,
we would occasionally lose sight if both the Resolution and the safe
boat as they disappeared behind a swell. During the recovery, the
safe boat's hull came down on a wing and damaged the winglet
attachment. Other than that, everything seemed to work fine, even
the hand off between the safe boat and the ship.
We took Malolo 1 back up to the bow and
did a quick 15 minute repair on the winglet. It was readied for
flight on the launcher again and was soon airborne for it's second
flight of the day. Happy with the results of the launcher tests and
successful take-offs with winds in excess of 20 kts, Curt brought the
Resolution around for landing after performing a beautiful loop. Low
and slow over the water, with it's head to the wind, the Resolution
was once again ready for touchdown when a rouge wave reached up and
grabbed the left wing. Malolo 1 did a graceful wing stand and ended
upside down in the ocean. The repaired winglet was once again
needing some repair but we called it a successful day and wrapped up
operations.
Overall, the fights were very
successful. We proved the functionality of the launcher, testing it
in winds higher than originally planned for. We found that landing
with 20-25 kt winds in the ocean has the expected increased risk,
although not necessarily a show stopper. The recovery with the safe
boat was doable but also has increased risk of possible damage and
the hand-off from the safe boat to the ship needs to be thought
through a bit more as that exposed but the airframe and the personnel
involved to a higher level of damage or injury.
Tomorrow, we plan on continuing flight
operations. This time with Malolo 2. In the meantime, we have made
repairs to Malolo 1's winglet and will have it ready for flight
tomorrow if needed.